Canadian Restitution cases L-N

Canadian cases L-N

Restitution
front page

What's new?

Another tree!

Australia
A-B
C-E
F-G
H-K
L-N
O-S
T-Z

Belize

Canada
A-B
C-E
F-G
H-K
L-N
O-S
T-Z

Caribbean Islands

Channel Islands

ECHR

England and
Wales
A-B
C-E
F-G
H-K
L-N
O-S
T-Z

Israel

Japan

Malaysia

New Zealand

Northern
Ireland

Pacific Islands

Philippines

Scotland

Singapore

South Africa

Sri Lanka

United
States
A-B
C-E
F-G
H-K
L-N
O-S
T-Z

Another tree!

Lac Minerals Ltd v. International Corona Resources Ltd
Supreme Court	11 August 1989	Constructive trust
(also here) (aussi en français)


Ladner v. Ladner
British Columbia Court of Appeal	28 June 2004	Constructive trust


Lang v. Jones
British Columbia Supreme Court	2 April 1997	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


Law Society of Upper Canada v. Toronto Dominion Bank
Ontario Court of Appeal	7 December 1998	Tracing
(also here)


Lazark v. Belcher
British Columbia Supreme Court	20 February 1997	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


LeClair v. LeClair
British Columbia Court of Appeal	7 May 1998	Breach of trust - constructive trust
(also here)


Leisner v. Russell
British Columbia Supreme Court	16 April 1998	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


Leong and Associates v. Watt
British Columbia Supreme Court	16 December 2003	Anticipated contract


Levine v. Dyer
British Columbia Supreme Court	13 August 1997	Rights between cohabitants
(also here)


Lewis v. Cantertrot Investments Ltd
Ontario Superior Court	20 March 2006	Class action certification


Liberale v. Spadafora
Ontario Superior Court	4 June 2008	Settlement – mistake


Lineham v. Forfert Estate
British Columbia Supreme Court	26 August 2003	Quantum meruit


Litemor Distributors (Edmonton) Ltd v. Midwest Furnishings and Supplies Ltd
Alberta Queen's Bench	8 July 2005	Quantum meruit
Alberta Queen's Bench	16 January 2007


Louie v. Lastman
Ontario Court of Appeal	17 September 2002	Fiduciary relationship � limitation


Lubrizol Corp v. Imperial Oil Ltd
Federal Court (CA)	3 April 1996	Account of profits
(also here and here) (aussi en français)


Luitenko v. McAleer
Alberta Court of Appeal	16 November 2009	Mortgage fraud - payment of mortgage - resulting trust


Lupul v. Carlson
Alberta Queen's Bench	7 June 2005	Improvements to property


Lust v. Canada
Federal Court of Appeal	15 February 2007	Shareholder loan
(aussi en français)


M v. H
Supreme Court	20 May 1999	Cohabitants' rights
(also here and here) (aussi en français)


MacFarlane v. Smith
New Brunswick Court of Appeal	30 January 2003	Cohabitants' rights
(aussi en français)


Shack Jang Mack v. A-G of Canada
Ontario Court of Appeal	13 September 2002	Tax wrongly demanded
(also here) (discussed here )


MacDonald v. MacDonald
British Columbia Supreme Court	12 February 2008	Cohabitants’ rights


Maclaren v. Romegioli
British Columbia Supreme Court	30 October 1996	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


MacLellan v. Morash
Nova Scotia Supreme Court	31 March 2006	Improvements to property


MacMichael v. Strocel
British Columbia Supreme Court	5 March 2009	Pension benefits
(Commentary on Rule of Law)


Madsen Estate v. Saylor
Supreme Court	3 May 2007	Presumption of advancement


Magellan Aerospace Ltd v. First Energy Capital Corp
Alberta Queen's Bench	26 September 2000	Mistake


Malazarte v. Agosti
British Columbia Supreme Court	23 December 1996	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


Malik (Estate of) v. State Petroleum Corporation
British Columbia Court of Appeal	16 November 2009	Oil concession - finder's fee - quantum meruit


Mandate National Mortgage v. 457189 BC Ltd
British Columbia Supreme Court	19 July 2004	Mistaken settlement


Manley v. Buckmaster
British Columbia Supreme Court	31 July 2000	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


Marcotte v. Longueuil (City)
Supreme Court	8 October 2009	Tax wrongly demanded - class action
(aussi en fran�ais)


Markson v. MBNA Canada Bank
Ontario Superior Court	21 October 2005	Class action – excessive interest
Ontario Court of Appeal	2 May 2007


Marvin v. Jagger
Manitoba Queen’s Bench	22 February 2008	Improvements to property


Martens v. Gulfstream Resources Canada Ltd
Alberta Queen's Bench	13 May 1998	Quantum meruit


Mathew and Co Ltd v. Minister of National Revenue
International Trade Tribunal	6 November 1997	Sales tax wrongly paid


May v. Saskatchewan
Saskatchewan Queen's Bench	27 March 2006	Fiduciary duty
Saskatchewan Court of Appeal	2 June 2006


McConnell v. Aviva Insurance Co of Canada Ltd
Alberta Queen's Bench	27 January 2006	Estoppel


Estate of McCunn v. Canadian Imperial Bank
Ontario Court of Appeal	15 February 2001	Mistake
(also here)


McCutcheon v. Cash Store Inc
Ontario Superior Court	10 May 2006	Excessive rate of interest


McLean Contracting Ltd v. Kelso
Alberta Queen's Bench	13 February 2002	Anticipated contract


McManus v. McCarthy
Alberta Queen’s Bench	21 December 2007	Conditional gift


McNamee v. McNamee
Ontario Court of Appeal	26 July 2011	Estate freeze - constructive trust


McVie v. Perry
British Columbia Supreme Court	31 July 1997	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


MD Management Ltd v. Monaghan
Alberta Provincial Court	10 December 1999	Mistake


Medley v. Medley
British Columbia Supreme Court	27 January 1997	Cohabitants' rights
British Columbia Court of Appeal	24 February 1999
(also here)


Merchant Law Group v. Canada (Revenue Agency)
Federal Court	24 July 2009	Tax wrongly paid


Michel v. Lafrentz
Alberta Court of Appeal	4 February 1999	Quantum meruit


Michelin Tires (Canada) Ltd v. R
Federal Court (CA)	7 May 2001	Overpaid tax
(also here) (aussi en français)


Miller v. Miller
British Columbia Supreme Court	24 January 2002	Contributions to family business


Miller Paving Ltd v. B Gottardo Construction Ltd
Ontario Superior Court	1 April 2005	Materials sold and delivered
Ontario Court of Appeal	7 June 2007


Minardi v. Clearly Canadian
British Columbia Supreme Court	16 January 2001	Quantum meruit


Minera Aquiline Argentina SA v. IMA Exploration Inc
British Columbia Supreme Court	14 July 2006	Confidence – constructive trust
British Columbia Court of Appeal	7 June 2007


M McGrath Canada Ltd v. Vincent Dagenais Gibson LLP
Ontario Superior Court	22 April 2008	Mistake


Mohammed v. York Fire and Casualty Insurance Co
Ontario Court of Appeal	14 February 2006	Mistaken settlement


Mollot v. Mollot
Alberta Queen's Bench	7 April 2006	Fiduciary duty
Alberta Court of Appeal	30 May 2007


Momi v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration)
Federal Court	3 November 2005	Fees wrongly demanded
Federal Court	12 June 2006
(aussi en français: ici et ici)


Monsanto Canada Inc v. Schmeiser
Federal Court	29 March 2001	Profit from infringement of patent
Supreme Court	21 May 2004
(aussi en français)


Montreuil v. Ontario Asphalt Co
Supreme Court	7 February 1922	Improvements to land


Moonen v. Moonen
British Columbia Supreme Court	6 March 1997	Contributions to property
(also here)


Moyes v. Ollerich Estate
British Columbia Court of Appeal	22 September 2005	Domestic services


Murphy v. MacDonald
Prince Edward Island Supreme Court	1 October 2009	Invalid lease - unrequested improvments


Mustard v. Brache
Alberta Court of Appeal	20 September 2006	Cohabitants’ rights – financial disclosure


Naidu v. Clemont
British Columbia Supreme Court	28 July 1998	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


Nanaimo Immigrant Settlement Society v. British Columbia
British Columbia Supreme Court	8 December 1999	Taxes wrongly charged
British Columbia Court of Appeal	6 February 2001


Nasser v. Meyer-Nasser
Ontario Court of Appeal	29 February 2000	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


National Bank of Greece (Canada) v. Bank of Montreal
Federal Court	24 September 1999	Cheques - the clearing system
(aussi en français)


National Gaming Corp v. Alberta Securities Commission
Alberta Queen's Bench	23 March 2000	Constructive trust - illegality


Neles Controls Ltd v. R
Federal Court	8 February 2001	Duty wrongly paid
(also here) (aussi en français)


Nelson v. Little Estate
Saskatchewan Court of Appeal	14 October 2005	Resulting trust


Nelson v. Nelson
Alberta Queen's Bench	20 August 2001	Husband and wife


Nemeth v. Timperly
British Columbia Supreme Court	7 April 1997	Cohabitants' rights
(also here)


Re New Skeena Forest Products Inc
British Columbia Supreme Court	7 June 2007	Tax credits – constructive trust


New Solutions Financial Corporation v. 952339 Ontario Ltd
Ontario Superior Court	3 January 2007	Failure of consideration


No 151 Cathedral Ventures Ltd v. Gartrell
British Columbia Supreme Court	1 December 2003	Breach of contract


Northwest Drywall and Building Supplies v. Flaming Brothers Construction
British Columbia Supreme Court	11 December 1996	Supply of building materials
British Columbia Court of Appeal	13 March 1998
(also here)


Nova Scotia (Attorney General) v. Walsh
Supreme Court	19 December 2002	Cohabitants' rights
(aussi en français)


NYK Line (Canada), Inc v. Canapak Seafoods
Nova Scotia Supreme Court	22 November 2002	Use of another's property

»
»
»
»
»

Case law courtesy of CANLII, LEXUM and the courts of Alberta, British Columbia and Ontario.
This page was compiled by Steve Hedley, to whom all comments should be addressed.
Many thanks to Sandra Bernstein for enhancements to this page.
All suggestions for improvement are very welcome !
Flags courtesy of 3DFlags and Multimedia Palace.

Shack Jang Mack v. A-G of Canada

Estate of McCunn v. Canadian Imperial Bank

Re New Skeena Forest Products Inc